13 Best Places to Stay in New Buffalo Michigan

Planning a getaway trip to New Buffalo, Michigan? You’re in for a treat! This charming and friendly lakeshore city offers exciting activities and attractions for everyone to enjoy. From its thriving downtown area with a picturesque marina to its beautiful beaches on Lake Michigan, New Buffalo delivers.

But before you set out to explore everything in the area, you need to find the perfect place to stay. Our guide to the best places to stay in New Buffalo, Michigan, intends to help you out with just that! If you’re on a budget or looking for a more luxurious experience on the New Buffalo beach, we’ve got you covered, so read on!

This article contains affiliate links and/or references to our advertisers. We may receive compensation when you click on or make a purchase using these links.

Getting to New Buffalo

If you’re coming from Indiana, Chicago, or another place in the state of Michigan, know that New Buffalo is located in Berrien County, in the southern part of Western Michigan, just north of Michigan City, Indiana on the shores of Lake Michigan. The Blue Water train from Chicago to Port Huron and the Wolverine train from Chicago to Detroit both stop at the Amtrak railroad station, which is located in the central business district.

Note: Train buffs will want to visit the New Buffalo Railroad Museum adjacent to the Amtrak station. Open on weekends, it has three restored railroad cars along with photographic exhibits. This attraction is often overlooked in favor of other activities, but we think it’s not to be missed.

Motorists will find the city conveniently located off I-94; use the US-12 exit if you’re westbound or the first exit past the New Buffalo Welcome Center just inside the state line if you’re eastbound.

What Are the Best Hotels in New Buffalo Michigan?

Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott New Buffalo

If you’re looking for a top-rated hotel in New Buffalo Michigan, you can’t go wrong with the Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott New Buffalo. This 3-star hotel has received rave reviews for its exceptional service, clean and spacious rooms, and great amenities like complimentary continental breakfast, free wi-fi internet, and indoor pool and hot tub.

The Harbor Grand

For a more luxurious stay, check out The Harbor Grand, a boutique hotel located right on the harbor. Their elegant guest rooms are on par with luxury hotels you’re used to, and feature plush bedding and private balconies with stunning views of the waterfront. Many have fireplaces and spa tubs, and each guest is provided with a comfortable spa robe while at the facility. Outdoor terrace dining and a relaxing spa retreat with a full array of personal service treatments are just a few of the luxury amenities at this thoughtfully designed hotel, one of the great resorts in the region.

The Holiday Inn Express & Suites New Buffalo

Family-friendly hotels are also abundant in New Buffalo Michigan. The Holiday Inn Express & Suites New Buffalo, affiliated with the IHG hotel family, is a popular choice among families, with its spacious rooms and complimentary buffet breakfast. All the amenities business travelers expect from the Holiday Inn Express & Suites brand are here: self-service laundry room, a business center, heated indoor pool and whirlpool, and fitness center.

What Are the Best Places to Stay in New Buffalo Michigan on a Budget?

New Buffalo Inn & Spa

If you’re looking for the best low-priced accommodations in New Buffalo Michigan, consider staying at the New Buffalo Inn & Spa. This cozy inn offers affordable rates and convenient access to the downtown area. Rooms feature Keurig coffee makers and smart TVs.

The Baymont by Wyndham New Buffalo

The Baymont by Wyndham New Buffalo is another great option, with its comfortable rooms, free continental breakfast, complimentary wireless internet access and short drive to Lake Michigan and outlet shopping.

Quality Inn Near Interstate I94 – Best Low Cost Option of Hotels in New Buffalo MI Near Four Winds Casino

If you want to to keep costs low and find hotels with the best deals in New Buffalo Michigan, keep an eye out for special promotions and discounts for non-refundable reservations, etc. The Quality Inn Near Interstate I94 offers affordable rates, free breakfast, and easy access to popular attractions like Four Winds Casino Resort and the Galien River County Park.

While average prices are climbing for the guest on a tight budget, your stay doesn’t have to be expensive and low prices at New Buffalo hotels can be had. There are plenty of cheap hotels in New Buffalo Michigan to choose from. To find the best time to book the cheapest hotels in New Buffalo Michigan, consider traveling during the fall or winter months when tourism levels lower. 

What Are the Most Convenient Hotels in New Buffalo Michigan?

If you want a hotel room close to the heart of the action, there are several hotels in New Buffalo Michigan that offer convenient access to the downtown area. The Baymont by Wyndham New Buffalo and Quality Inn Near Interstate I94 are both located just a short drive from the city center, making it easy to explore all of the shops, restaurants, and attractions. For those looking to soak up some sun at the shore, The Harbor Grand is located near Lake Michigan.

New Buffalo Bed and Breakfast: The Neighborhood Hotel

If you’re looking for something a bit more intimate, the Neighborhood Hotel is an adults-only, nine-room bed and breakfast inn located right in downtown New Buffalo, a ten-minute walking distance from the beach Their cozy rooms feature free wifi, Ralph Lauren linens, flat screen TVs with Netflix, air conditioning and mini-fridges. Choose a terrace room or one with a balcony. Fresh-baked cookies are often available in the common area, too. Note that their free parking area can fill up quickly, so plan accordingly.

If you’re planning on visiting Galien River County Park, consider staying at the Holiday Inn Express & Suites New Buffalo, the Quality Inn Near I94 or the Fairfield Inn. These hotels are just a short drive from the park, making it easy to explore its hiking trails and wildlife viewing opportunities.

What Is the Best Lakeside Resort in New Buffalo Michigan?

The Harbor Grand (Again)

If you want to experience the ultimate in lakeside living, then consider staying at one of the top-rated lakeside resorts in New Buffalo Michigan. The Harbor Grand Resort offers luxurious accommodations with views of the New Buffalo harbor. The Harbor Grand hotel features full resort amenities such as a luxury day spa, sophisticated dining, relaxing common areas and atmospheric rooms with views, fireplaces and hot tubs.

What Are the Best Vacation Rental Options in New Buffalo Michigan?

If you’re looking for a home away from home in the New Buffalo area, then a vacation rental might be the perfect option for you. Lakefront vacation rentals are particularly popular in New Buffalo Michigan, with a remarkable option like the New Buffalo Lakefront House, which is directly on the beach with a saltwater swimming pool and hot tub.

For an in-town experience, the Bradford New Designer Luxury Cottage has a heated pool and sleeps 12, perfect for a multi-generational family vacation or a friends group getaway. Located in a serene residential neighborhood, shops and the beach are just steps away.

For the quintessential Lake Michigan cottage experience, check out the Charming Cottage or the Tallgrass Cottage. These homes feature all the amenities you need, kitchen facilities, comfortable sleeping, and relaxing ambiance.

If you want to be near Four Winds Casino New Buffalo, consider staying at one of the vacation rentals located nearby. The charming Storybook Cottage and the tranquil Deer House both offer easy access to the casino and all its games and amenities.

Tip: For atmospheric eats in New Buffalo, check out the Stray Dog Bar & Grill, Redamak’s, and Oink’s Dutch Treat.

Still Undecided? Use Our Handy Interactive Map to Choose and Book Your Stay

As you can see, there are plenty of amazing places to stay in New Buffalo Michigan, no matter what your budget or preferences may be. Whether you’re a business traveler, a family on holiday, or just looking to explore the area, you’re sure to find the perfect place to call home during your stay.

Note: For other ideas to New Buffalo’s North, check out our post on the 5 Best Small Towns in Michigan on Lake Michigan